Friday, January 26, 2018

A Glimpse Into Sub Life, Take 2

Simple but oh so effective 
    The school year is half-way over, and I have been in a grand total of 10 different buildings. I've taught kindergarten through 12th grade (I was only in kindergarten for an hour... thank God!), and I've been in schools with thousands of kids and in schools with barely 100.
    Today, I subbed in a middle school English classroom and during the teacher's prep I was asked to cover another English teacher's class. To be honest, I was a bit crabby at the news. I get it. We used to do the same thing to subs in our building. We were told to utilize subs to the Nth degree... use them for recess duty and lunch duty and anything else we could think of. But I was looking forward to reading the book I had brought along, and I really wasn't excited about finding my way to an unfamiliar classroom during the 3 minutes of passing time and then having approximately 30 seconds between looking at the lesson and the bell ringing.
     It all worked out. The kids were great. The lesson was a piece of cake. However, most notable was the room itself. This teacher is a rockstar, evident just by the organization of the cozy room. I thought I would share some of the teacher's rockstar-ism.
    I had to ask a girl about the tickets because those caught my attention. The student explained that the teacher gives a ticket to a student when he/she is doing something "good", and then there is a weekly drawing and the winner of the drawing earns rights to the coveted classroom rocking chair for the following week. Sweet classroom management plan. Rockstar. For sure.

This just made me laugh.
Middle school classroom management at its finest.















Such an awesome community builder. What is
more welcoming than walking into a classroom
where you feel a part of things?!

Sunday, January 21, 2018

Insights from The Book Whisperer

I read The Book Whisperer by Donalyn Miller nearly six years ago, the summer before my first year of teaching middle school English. The title had been recommended in some other source, and I remember being mildly surprised when I found it available in the local public library. I checked it out with little expectation, and I remember devouring the book in one sitting. Many tenets of the book have stuck with me, and I decided to revisit it during this teaching hiatus of mine.

Here are the major points that stick with me this second time around.

1. Miller devoutly believes that our mission as teachers of reading is not to develop successful test takers but to develop life-long readers. She recognizes the reality of today's students. Many students do not think of reading as a fun pastime. Many students do not like reading and associate it with boring tests, boring topics, and well... just with boring. Miller believes that in order to turn the tide, we must create life-long readers by allowing students to read lots and lots of books from a variety of genres that they choose to read. She asks her sixth graders to read FORTY books by the end of the school year. She believes readers are made, not born.

2. Miller does not teach the whole-class novel. She teaches comprehension strategies and literary elements that her students apply to their independent reading books. She states, "Every single lesson that I teach circles back to students' own reading..." (35).

3. Miller uses reading inventories/surveys in her class as a way to connect students with books, and she encourages these connections relentlessly. Miller recalls a student who rejected TWENTY books that she suggested before finally accepting one skeptically. Miller illustrates the importance of refusing to give up on a kid and staunchly maintaining that all students in the class are readers.

4. Miller cites the report Becoming a Nation of Readers, which recommends that students engage in two hours of silent sustained reading a week. The only way to ensure that students read is to give them time to read in class every day. Miller starts every day with independent reading time, and this reading time is sacred.

5. Many students (and even some parents) will balk at the 40 book requirement. Miller says the key is "to celebrate milestones with students and focus on their reading successes, not their failure to meet requirements"(83).  I love the questions she uses to focus on the reading successes:
          a) Did you read more than you thought you would?
          b) How many more books have you read this year compared to last year? (She uses a sport analogy, asking her student athletes if their coaches would be ecstatic about a 200% improvement in their performance. Um yeah, these coaches would be STOKED)
          c) Have you read books that you enjoyed?

Miller offers several practical pieces of advice that I latched onto when I first read her book, and I have implemented these practices into my own classroom, and they definitely helped me run a smooth(er) reading workshop. I haven't discussed them in my post, yet they are another reason to get a copy of her book.

My biggest gripe about this book is that she gives little guidance about how to incorporate a grading system into this workshop approach. It's difficult to give a kid kudos for reading ten books by December when last year they hadn't finished even one book, and then in the next breath tell them that their efforts earn them a C. This is the missing piece for me, and I'm hoping her second book sheds some light on how she handles this.

Wednesday, January 17, 2018

Reading Update: The Woman in Cabin 10 by Ruth Ware

A dark thriller that takes you on a ride with so many twists you are definitely holding on with both hands by the end - even if you're one of those daring rebels who laugh wildly down Magic Mountain with both hands in the air and have the coolest picture in the relic shop. Even you.

Lo Blacklock is a journalist who just scored the story of her career when she's asked to replace her boss on a luxurious cruise ship and to report back on the ship, the fellow guests, and the trip. It becomes quickly apparent that Lo is unstable with a drinking problem and low self-esteem. This instability causes much skepticism from fellow passengers and crew when she claims a woman staying in the cabin next door to hers has disappeared off the ship. For various reasons, Lo persists in determining the whereabouts of this mysterious woman, and her persistence leads to dark secrets.

The writing is reminiscent of Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca with the prose lending itself to a constant mood of mystery and suspense. I was so absorbed in the writing that I literally shook my head a couple of times when I was transitioning from reading as if to break the trance.

I had a couple issues with the writing. The conversations between Lo and her lover seemed stilted. The subplot of their relationship either needed to be more developed or lessened because some of these scenes just sounded out-of-tune. In addition, the author lives in London and the story is based in London, and some of the British-isms escaped me. I realize this is a conceited complaint, but it was one problem I had with the book nevertheless.

The language and the sexual content wouldn't make this appropriate for middle school, and I would never assign this as required reading in any classroom, but I could see it being recommended as a fun read for more mature high schoolers.

Reading Update: Monster by Walter Dean Myers

This is one quick read. I literally read it in about two hours on a wintry January night. For those reluctant readers, especially those middle school boys, who might be in your classroom, this would be a great pick. It's short, it's intense, and it has a strong message.

Steve Harmon is a 16-year-old accused of murder, and the book starts with him sitting in a jail cell preparing for his trial and it ends with the outcome of the trial - which I won't give away.

The format of the story is a film script, which I can't say I enjoyed. I found the camera angles and "stage directions" distracting, and I found myself skimming these lines to get back to the plot. I could see some middle schoolers struggling with these excerpts and finding them distracting, too.

The book would fit well into a unit about identity or truth. There is some language in the book that could raise concern, so I would clear it with the admin and get parent permission if you make it a required reading in your class.

Reading Update: Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

My sister recommended this book to me many years ago, and for whatever reason, I never got to it. I truly believe it was divine intervention that caused me to finally pick up this book when I did. With six months of marriage under my belt, I am by no means wise in the means of wedded bliss but I do believe that being married brings a different- and valuable- insight to this read.

The topic of love is inexhaustible. Unrequited love. Platonic love. Devoted love. Fleeting infatuation. Intoxicating love. Lustful love. Jealous love. Selfless love. In his book, Marquez explores so many facets and helps to broaden my understanding in how love can take many forms throughout a lifetime and to question the idea that there is one true definition of love.

I think most of us are aware of the theory that Disney romance and the conventional notion of love portrayed in Hollywood films has left many generations with an unrealistic impression of love. According to the big screen, it's breathtaking and giggly, and the loving couple sails into an everlasting forever that is all smooth sailing.

Marquez reveals the "realness" of love. It's messy. It's painful. And yet, it's oh so worth pursuing. Two particular passages stood out to me, and I don't think they would have been so poignant to me prior to marriage.

"In the end they knew each other so well that by the time they had been married for thirty years they were like a single divided being, and they felt uncomfortable at the frequency with which they guessed each other's thoughts without intending to, or the ridiculous accident of one of them anticipating in public what the other was going to say. Together they had overcome the daily incomprehension, the instantaneous hatred, the reciprocal nastiness and fabulous flashes of glory in the conjugal conspiracy. It was the time when they loved each other best, without hurry or excess, when both were most conscious of and grateful for their incredible victories over adversity. Life would still present them with other mortal trials, of course, but that no longer mattered: they were on the other shore" (272). 

This passage stands out to me because a strong marriage, in fact a strong relationship of any kind, is built on kindness, honesty, and consideration. Yet, it's so true that any long-lasting relationship is not going to be smooth sailing. There will be choppy waters, and enduring those difficult times are indeed worthy of celebration and a sense of achievement.

"Over the years they both reached the same wise conclusion by different paths: it was not possible to live together in any other way, or love in any other way, and nothing in this world was more difficult than love" (270). 

The context of this passage is that a husband and wife, Dr. Juvenal Urbino and Fermina Daza respectively, have appreciated the contributions of the other. Dr. Juvenal Urbino attempts to carry out his wife's daily duties around the house, and this intelligent, successful man experiences utter failure by 11 a.m. Obviously, times have changed, and women's contributions to the home and to the marriage aren't restricted to household errands and chores, but I think the point illustrated here is critical. I think it is important between a husband and wife to discuss one another's "roles" per se and not only to ensure that things get done but to be aware of what one another is doing. If you're not aware, you're not appreciative, and if you're not appreciative, things can fall apart.

Practical Considerations:
Using this book with middle schoolers? No way.  I would even be reluctant to put this book in the hands of high schoolers because I don't think many of them have the life experience to fully appreciate Marquez's messages. In addition to the maturity of the content, Marquez's prose is difficult. He reminded me of a South American version of Hawthorne. Using this book as a gift for newlyweds? So going to happen.

Sunday, January 14, 2018

The Literature Workshop: Authentic Interpretations

Here are some of the highlights from Sheridan D. Blau's chapter "Where Do Interpretations Come From?" in his book The Literature Workshop. In this chapter, Blau addresses the need for students to build confidence in their ability to "interpret" literature on their own.

"Scholes (Robert Scholes 1999) urges teachers to rescue literature from test makers and from student indifference by helping students see how it speaks to them as human beings rather than as test takers and technical analysts. And the first step toward that goal, for many teachers, he says, is to drop those writing assignments that focus on technical features of literary works (irony, theme, symbol, ect) " (102).

As a teacher of writing, I have lamented (and have heard lamentations from many other writing teachers) the lack of engagement and critical thinking that my students display in their writing. I twist every little sentence out of them, and by the end of the writing unit, I've been put through the wringer as much as they have. I'm exhausted, and I still don't feel like the student writing shows what my students can do because the ideas (and even some of the words and sentences) are mine - if I'm being honest with myself as I grade. What would my students do if I asked them to reflect authentically on a piece of literature and to write about their own personal interpretation? Would they have the confidence to do so? Would they flounder in a bewildered manner, beseeching me for an interpretation because the freedom and the faith in their thinking would be so unfamiliar to them? Blau argues that we should build confidence in our students by giving them the freedom to think about their reading and to form their own interpretations of the literature.


"First, it (the workshop) usually shows students that they are experienced interpreters of stories and that interpretation is not an activity that necessarily requires specialized training in English classes. Second, they see that their interpretations did not tend to focus on literary devices, and that what they did have to say was generally more important to say and more respectful of the story as an engaging narrative than any schooled observations they might have mechanically offered about literary devices" (114). 

Are we de-valuing literature when we ask our students to read a narrative and then ask them what they noticed about the tone? Didn't the writer intend for a more purposeful response than that? Literature seems to me to be one of the most natural subjects to lend itself to relevancy as students make their own connections and their own interpretations, yet we as teachers so often ignore this teaching opportunity. In addition, we want our students to think, and yet so many of our lessons and assignments strip our students of authentic thinking opportunities because we merely ask them to regurgitate what was lectured in class or what can be found on Sparknotes. I get the dilemma here. We often provide those stilted prompts because we have standardized tests to prepare these students for. They're going to see questions about tone, theme, symbolism, irony, ect. and we need to get them ready for those questions. Yet, Blau challenges us to expect more of our students and to prepare our students for bigger and better things than questions on the standardized test. By asking them to build confidence in their own interpretations, we're preparing them for a life of critical thinking and joyful reading.

Saturday, January 6, 2018

The Literature Workshop: Thinking in the Writing Assignment

I stumbled across The Literature Workshop: Teaching Texts and Their Readers by Sheridan D. Blau when I was perusing Kelly Gallagher's Web site. On his blog, Gallagher had listed his top 15 favorite professional texts, and Blau's book was near the top of his list. I added the title to my Amazon wishlist, Christmas arrived, and this unpretentious text is my favorite gift from the holiday season. It's a rather small volume as professional texts go, and there's nothing flashy about the book, but whoofta, is it a gold mine of ideas!

Blau titles Chapter 7 of his book "Writing Assignments in Literature Classes: The Problem" and his analysis is so spot-on that I decided to dedicate a blog post to the illuminating chapter. Blau laments the lack of thinking found in so many secondary students' writing, and I am quick to agree that after I've read 20 class essays and still have 80 more to go, they've all started sounding the same. The ideas in the students' writing do not veer from any of the "safe" topics that were discussed in class, and very few students promote any independent thinking of their own.

Although it's easy to point the finger at the students and groan, "Ugh, they just won't think," Blau aptly notes that the way in which a teacher frames the assignment generally produces the papers it deserves. Touche.

I find at the middle school level, much of my instruction is focused on structure rather than content. My rubric contains criteria such as "a clear topic sentence in each body paragraph is supported by at least two pieces of textual evidence adequately explained". Many students at the middle school level require the scaffolding that I automatically provide with Step-Up to Writing outlines, and yet I also have had many students over the years who are ready to fly. They're ready to deviate from the formulaic writing prescribed by Step-Up because they "get" how to organize their essay. They're now ready to explore and experiment.

So there's framing mistake #1 on my part. Upon reflection, I think I have focused too much on structure, and in doing so, have stifled the importance of thinking. My second mistake is the stuffy prompts I often assign such as "What is the theme of this story?" Sounds open-ended enough on the surface, but if you've been in the classroom, you would know that we have beaten theme statements over-the-head relentlessly for probably near two weeks, and students have been buried in discussion about theme so that by the time students start drafting, it'd be difficult for them to come up with an original theme that has not already been discussed.

I'm curious if any other middle school English teachers (or perhaps high school teachers, too) find themselves focusing more on structure rather than on thinking? I'm also curious if anybody feels like I do in that some students have become reliant on the teacher to provide outlines and despite having "written" a handful of essays would be at a complete loss if the teacher didn't provide a graphic organizer complete with RDFs and Explains.

It's these very students who make me most reluctant to push students off the diving board into the "thinking pool" because I fear the lesson/unit/project/assignment would drown with a satisfying gurgle. How do you train students to think and ease them in, starting in the baby pool and moving steadily to the deep end? What's too much scaffolding and what's not enough? These are rhetorical questions, I know, because there is no right answer. Each class is different. Each student is different. But these are the questions I grapple with in my pursuit to provide the best learning experience for my kids.

Sunday, December 17, 2017

Reading Update: My Sister's Keeper

I will admit it. I cried on this one. I honestly can say that I don't remember the last time a book made me cry, but this one got me. My Sister's Keeper by Jodi Picoult was published in 2004 so it is not a new read, but for some reason, I had never read it before - or Jodi Picoult for that matter. And what a discovery I have made!
    Picoult's masterful writing called for the re-reading of some beautifully crafted passages. Take this one for example when two of the characters are watching shooting stars:
     But Anna keeps her eyes glued to the upended bowl of the heavens. "I know you want to ask me why I'm doing all this."
     You don't have to say anything if you don't want to." 
     Anna lies down, her head pillowed against my shoulder. Every second, another streak of silver glows: parentheses, exclamation points, commas - a whole grammar made of light, for words too hard to speak" (200).
     In addition to powerful writing, the storyline is compelling and 423 pages slip by. To briefly summarize the story without giving away too much, it's about a family's journey as they cope with their child's terminal cancer. Kate was diagnosed with leukemic cancer at the age of 2, and Brian and Sarah, Kate's parents, decided to have a designer baby, Anna, who would be genetically identical to Kate in order to help Kate's body fight the cancer.  From the moment of her birth, Anna's body was used to provide spare parts for Kate, and finally at the age of 13, Anna sues her parents and files for medical emancipation as they ask her to give Kate one of her kidneys, knowing that by refusing to give a kidney she is condemning her sister to die. Anna's decision causes the family and the court system to try to find the "right" answer in an unprecedented situation.
P.S. I watched the film adaptation after finishing the book. Consensus: Skip the movie and read the book. There is no comparison.

Practical Considerations:
     The length of this book and the various points of view would make me cautious in recommending this book to middle school students or to high school readers who struggle. A different character narrates each chapter and the changing point of view could be challenging for young and/or struggling readers. The delicate topic also calls for mature readers.

Saturday, December 2, 2017

Classroom Reading Program - Thank you, Readicide

    A little too much time has passed since my last post, but as  I sip some coffee and wait for the cable guys to show up (nothing too romantic this morning), I find myself appreciating the slower pace. I haven't been reading any professional texts for the last two weeks, but I think my mind has slowly been digesting the information I've eagerly pored over during my teaching hiatus.
    So, I, like, get it. Kids need to read. And they need a balanced diet of informational text and fiction. And they need choice. And relevance. And embedded reading skill minilessons. They need to be held accountable for doing the reading, and the reading should challenge them. In lots of ways.
    I like Kelly Gallagher's suggested Article of the Week. I agree that many people (including both teens and adults in this category) are ignorant of important local, state, and national news, and I think the opportunity for students to stay abreast of current affairs should be built into the school day.
     I like that Gallagher holds his students accountable for reading one book a month. If we preach that students need to read, then we should expect that students read. Like Gallagher, I think it's important to provide time in class for students to read independently books of their own choosing. I understand some kids have homes that are not conducive for silent reading, and I also believe that carving out precious classroom time sends the message that this type of reading is important. And it is.
     After finishing Gallagher's book Readicide, I agree with him that so many of our students relate reading to boring passages that are followed by multiple-choice comprehension questions. Unfortunately, so many students have missed the opportunity to learn that reading can be fun. It's essential that students learn that often we read simply for pleasure; therefore, asking students to read books of their own choosing and consistently providing students time to do this reading is a staple of my classroom reading program.
     This last thought in regard to reading dawned on me as I skimmed Instagram photos and caught up with the lives of friends who crossed my path many, many years ago. I discovered that one of my friends bought a fixer-upper with her new husband, and they spend every waking moment (and every spare penny) turning the house into a home. Another friend was able to come home to central Montana for Thanksgiving despite her demanding work schedule. However, it's this third Instagram post that got my wheels spinning.
    In this post, a friend was vacationing in South Africa with her husband. However, her previous posts showed her in Tuscany; Spain; London; Munich. I realized she wasn't on a grand European tour but this nomadic lifestyle is her norm. So, naturally, I wanted to know what she does for work. She is a total rewards director for Microsoft. After learning this tidbit, I next wanted to know what exactly a total rewards director does. After a bit of Google research, I learned that total rewards directors help put together benefit packages for employees of corporations. Then, ahem, I googled the average salary of total rewards directors. Salaries varied widely, but I would say 200k seems to be a realistic expectation. And I thought to myself, "Wow, good for her. I've never even heard of a job like this."
    And that's when I had my "aha" moment. Students probably haven't heard of her job either, but it sure would be cool if they did before they head off to college and declare a major. With the staggering cost of college, it's be nice to make as many informed decisions as possible during those college-tuition years because nobody wants to waste thousands of dollars switching from one major to another, or even worse, graduate after four expensive years and realize that they actually would prefer to do something else. I also don't want my students to pigeon-hole themselves into a career path simply because they don't know any different.
     So, on top of the AoW assignment and the monthly independent reading book, I would also include regular reading assignments about careers. Imagine if students explored a different career choice each week. By the end of the school year, students will have been exposed to approximately 36 different careers... which is a heck of a lot more than I ever considered before packing my bags and heading off to college.

Sunday, November 19, 2017

Reading Update: Frank McCourt


"I'm in New York, land of the free and home of the brave, but I'm supposed to behave as if I were still in Limerick, Irish at all times.... I don't know why I returned to America if I have to listen to the sad stories of Ireland's sufferings and dance with country girls, Mullinger heifers, beef to the heels" ('Tis, 206).
    To say I have been enthralled, inspired, mortified, and raptly entertained by Frank McCourt's books might begin to convey how highly I recommend his writing. In Angela's Ashes, he recounts his poverty-stricken childhood in Limerick, Ireland, and 'Tis doesn't skip a beat in picking up his life story as he moves to New York, alone and 18 years of age. Teaching Man shares McCourt's insights from his 30 years in the classroom, which are also vastly entertaining, inspiring, and sometimes mortifying.

Angela's Ashes
   I was slightly shocked when reading Angela's Ashes that I had never considered the hardships other countries had endured during the Great Depression. Frankly, I was embarrassed that I knew so little about Ireland. McCourt's memoir made me thankful for running water, electricity, enough food to eat, clean clothes, and a warm home in the winter. As I experienced McCourt's childhood, I not only felt gratefulness but also amazement at the resiliency of children. His story is mesmerizing, but his writing style somehow enhances the narrative. His Irish-"isms" and style breathe life into the poor neighbors along the lane, the crotchety grandmother, the hoity-toity aunt, the drunken brawling father, and all of the other rich characters who help create the colorful tapestry of McCourt's childhood.
     I would reserve this book for older high school students due to the foul language and sexual content. In addition, the book is so moving, and I would hate to expose students to this book who are too young to truly appreciate the story.

'Tis
    At the beginning of 'Tis, McCourt is a fresh "Paddy off the boat" and learns some hard lessons as, alone, he adjusts to the American lifestyle and strange American mannerisms. Scrubbing toilets in hotels, fighting overseas in the Korean War, working on the docks, and putting himself through night school to become a teacher, McCourt's life is no less adventurous than his childhood in Ireland. Perhaps, most notable is the inner turmoil McCourt suffers as he attempts to honor his Irish heritage and yet form for himself an identity in his new home of New York City.
    'Tis follows Angela's Ashes, yet it would be possible to read 'Tis without reading Angela's Ashes - although this would not be my recommendation. Due to sexual content and strong language, I would reserve this book for an older audience.

Teacher Man
"I was more than a teacher. And less. In the high school classroom you are a drill sergeant, a rabbi, a shoulder to cry on, a disciplinarian, a singer, a low-level scholar, a clerk a referee, a clown, a counselor, a dress-code enforcer, a conductor, an apologist, a philosopher, a collaborator, a tap dancer, a politician, a therapist, a fool, a traffic cop, a priest, a mother-father-brother-sister-uncle-aunt, a bookkeeper, a critic, a psychologist, the last straw" (19). 
    McCourt summarizes it well. I wouldn't recommend Teacher Man to my students, but it may be one of my new recommendations for fellow teachers, especially those who need a breath of fresh air. 
    I will say that I was surprised by the teaching tenets that McCourt references from his career in the 1960s and 70s. Stand by the door to greet students, engage the students, make the lesson relevant, provide enrichment... little has changed in what is regarded as "expert" teaching after nearly 50 years, and yet, we're still trying to master it...

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

Major Takeaways from Readicide

"I introduce 'readicide' here because it cuts to the central ironic thesis of this book: rather than helping students, many of the reading practices found in today's classroom are actually contributing to the death of reading" (2)
I thought I would begin with the premise of Kelly Gallagher's book Readicide: How Schools are Killing Reading and What You Can Do About It. Done.


"Students may or may not like the novel, but I want all of them to  understand the value that comes from reading it" (57).
We're human. We want acceptance. We want to be liked. I have never aspired to be that teacher who causes a student to crinkle her nose in disgust and mutter, "I hate that class." Yet, not all students who take my class are going to like every book, every assignment, or every project. That's a fact. Gallagher's statement is a reminder that I'm not in the classroom to be the students' friend nor am I there to ensure they like every book we read. Instead, I'm there to help them find the value in the literature we read and the value in the learning activities I ask them to engage in. I'm there to help them learn.


"Students need to be reintroduced to the notion that we read for enjoyment. To help my students achieve this goal, I have adopted a 50/50 approach in my classroom. To mix up the reading diet of my students, I want  half of their reading to be academic, and I want half of their reading to be recreational" (84). 
    Ok. It blows my mind that one of the most renowned high school English teachers in the country is attempting a 50/50 approach in his classroom. I've read Atwell's In the Middle and Miller's The Book Whisperer, and both of these inspiring educators used a reading workshop approach in the middle grades - but a high school teacher implementing this approach? Not too common.
     My kids absolutely love reading workshop day, which I have typically saved for the last day of the week. Yet, even this one designated day is not sacred, and sometimes students have a mere 20 minutes of free reading time on Fridays. If students could spend 50 percent of the time reserved for reading on recreational reading, they'd enjoy the class a whole lot more. Heck, they might even like reading. Touche, Mr. Gallagher.


Big Chunk/Little Chunk Approach: "In the simplest terms, students do a lot of first-draft reading of large chunk of text on their own (after initial framing from the teacher). This is followed with second-and-third draft close readings of excerpts in the classroom (which require teacher expertise)" (99). 
     I have been guilty of assigning chapters of reading and asking students to close-read the entire thing. I tell them I want to see annotations and evidence of close reading. Sometimes students are given a purpose for their close reading and sometimes they're told to simply note what they notice. Confusion becomes a tangible thing in my middle school classroom when I've done this. 
     In my humble opinion, students shouldn't be asked to close read entire chapters. Should they close-read an article after being given a purpose for the reading? Sure, no problem. But entire chapters? That's tedious. That's readicide. 
   It makes complete sense to me that students read large parts of the texts independently with a reading purpose, and then they closely re-read an excerpt identified by the teacher. If the teacher is unable to identify an excerpt that warrants close reading, then the text should probably be challenged as one not worthy of being read in the class.

Reading Update: Immigration Issues

Hola! I've been absent on the blog and you might think I've had a quiet couple months, but I have been caught up in a reading frenzy...